For those of you who don’t know this, Crab Theory is a theory that the Deaf community uses to explain why so many successful D/deaf people are so often viciously criticized or “pulled down” by other, presumably less successful D/deaf persons. The phenomenon has supposedly been observed in crabs that have been placed in a bucket. Whenever one tries to climb out, the others through sheer startle reflex drag it back down. Translation: because I am threatened, not only can you not be better than me, but your chances for escape from our circumstances must never be better than mine.
For those of you who have long since become tired of the hold (well, pinch) that Crab Theory has over our community, I have created below a list of five maneuvers for overcoming it.
1) The “Outlet” Maneuver
Stand in the midst of the crabs and hold up a DVD. Shout, “I have created a visual presentation that will teach us to work together in harmony!” Then look around for an electrical outlet to plug the projector into. When you can’t find one in the bucket (surprise!) tell the other crabs not to worry, you’ll be right back—you just have to climb out of the bucket and find a place to plug it in. Then simply don’t return.
2) The “Medical” Maneuver
Overlapping terminology used by both the “medical malady” camp and the “linguistic/cultural minority” camp has confused this community to the point of hostile paranoia. So run around inside the bucket screaming “I know a way out! I know a way out!” This will startle the broadest range of crabs (both upper- and lower-case “c”) as badly as possible, causing them to indiscriminately pile on. Drag yourself—and them—to the nurse’s office. When she asks you what’s wrong, sputter out a choked response of “C…crabs!” While your meaning is technically open to interpretation, in a nurse’s office, there will be more than enough disgust and revulsion (albeit for a wide variety of reasons) to make everyone let go. So be ready. Amidst their furious shrieks, sprint for the side of the bucket, climb up, and get free.
3) The “Administrative” Maneuver
Tell the other crabs that you have a plan for creating a sophisticated and structured pyramid that will serve as a ladder everyone can use to escape from the bucket. Then supervise the proceedings. The base of the pyramid must be steadied with interlocking claws and shells. The integrity of its second level, similarly, must be strengthened by tying eyestalks together. And finally, its pinnacle must be the firmest level of all, requiring a grip of iron and the utmost concentration upon the levels below. When the pyramid is finished (that is to say, when all the other crabs can neither move nor see) prance to the top, climb over the edge of the bucket, and get out.
4) The “Mission Impossible” Maneuver
Acidic bile can be obtained from the internal chemical mixtures of resentment and petty jealousy. Generate this constantly until ample amounts have been manufactured. Secrete said acidic bile along the seam where the floor of the bucket meets the walls. This will further advance whatever impact the natural process of rotting has already had on the infrastructure. Then wait for a giant hand to pick up the bucket. The bottom will fall out, sending a confused spray of water and crabs in all directions. Prepare yourself for this moment by studying that scene from Mission Impossible where Tom Cruise blows up a fish tank with a piece of explosive gum. See how he practically rides the wave out of the restaurant in the midst of the panic? With any luck you’ll be far and away before the giant hand can find a new bucket.
5) The “Harassment” Maneuver
As you attempt to climb up out of the bucket, your backside will be exposed. This makes your next move obvious. When the crabs below are startled into pulling you back down, simply scream “Stop grabbing my backside!” Get the incident on tape and sue the nearest crab for workplace harassment. Then get the EEOC to label the whole place a hostile environment and net yourself a fat settlement. The giant hand might even give you a transfer to a better bucket!
© Copyrighted material. This article cannot be copied, reproduced or redistributed without the express written consent of the author. As with every blog on this website, this blog does not reflect the opinion of DeafDC.com.
23 Comments
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.


Damn! That was a great article. I found myself laughing so hard. What a concept!
I also need to say that Crab Theory isn’t just the Deaf Communities problem, its also other cultures, races and genders.
But seriously, this whole crab thing with our own community is getting out of control, because in this day and age, it is becoming more of a global thing now. So someone over in Alaska or Guantamala heard abt so and so, and thinks they better not hire or talk to them…
Ugh!
:-)
True. For women, it’s called Tall Poppy Syndrome. (The tall ones get cut short.)
We have a similar sort of thing in the Pagan Community as well…it’s most generally called “The Witch Wars” but is also informally known as “bitchcraft.”
Hahaha!
Got a chuckle out of this one!
I did too. I feel bad for the crabs (literally!) Now thanks to this article, when I see a basket of crabs, I will think of this too and feel even more badder for the crabs trying to get out of the basket just to go home and survive.
That is what life is about, surviving, I dont need no theory to tell me that. LOL.
The crab theory is not a good way to describe it, funny as your satire is.
Crabs always try to climb out of where they are, and will grab onto anything to pull themselves up, including another crab. Mindlessly it keeps grabbing and pulling itself up till it climbs over the other crab, and is soon followed by others. Eventually they all get out, and the last crab, the poor leader, finally gets his chance.
Try the Australian-Asian proverb of the “tall poppy” syndrome; the tallest poppy in the field will get cut back.
Personally, I’m getting tired of the “crab syndrome” because it is so insulting to the Deaf community. Most of us are better than that.
Agreed but there are a few that do make an effort to bring others back down and criticize too harshly.
According to some sociologists’ and sociolinguists’ observations, crab antics not only exist in the Deaf community but also exist in all ethnicities.
Got a good chuckle out of me! I loved the ‘Mission Impossible’ maneuver! It doesn’t hurt to have a little bit of satire to shed a different light on our faultlines within our community.
Classic. Especially the “I have crabs” bit!
Yes, that was funny *chuckle*. I enjoyed your article, god knows, we need a laugh once in a while…
Good readin’ Enjoyed this one!
*laughing*
LOL! How do you come up with these topics? :)
Ella Mae Lentz, in her excellent vlog a while back, raised the following questions… how did the bucket get there and who put us (the crabs) in there? Do a satire of that, hmm? :)
Here is the link of her awesome vlog:
http://www.joeybaer.com/?p=11
I love #5! No pinching with those pinchers, crabbies! Hilarious.
Loved it! The funny thing for me was the tongue-in-cheek “truthfulness” that could be found in these maneuvers…
Good one, Chris!
Now, how about doing the Boiled Lobster Theory?
While I know your article was mostly tongue-in-cheek, I personally don’t believe in the existence of the infamous Crab Theory.
I’ve never personally experienced it, and I try very hard to be supportive of Deaf-culture/ASL-friendly Deaf people whenever possible.
The only time I don’t get support (or get criticized) are times when I adopt an openly pro-Deaf culture stance or pro-ASL stance. So I’ve come to believe that the so-called Crab Theory (at least for me anyway) is performed by these ‘culturally blind’ (a.k.a. ‘brainwashed’) people who don’t want to see Deaf culture and ASL to succeed and grow.
Maybe it’s time we took a closer look at WHO practices Crab Theory and their motivations.
-Michele Ketcham
Hilarious!
I’m not sure if you intended that or not, but I can see the correlations in the five different “methods” for getting out of the bucket that could illustrate to things that the Deaf community has been subjected to (such as the medical method) or has used on others (mission impossible and harassment).
So funny. And a paragon of truthiness, to steal a word from the current political world!