When Manny Ramirez got caught using a banned substance, baseball purists said he should never get admission into the shrine of baseball.
I was one of these baseball purists. Not anymore.
Not only Manny, but also Alex Rodriguez, Sammy Sosa, Mark McGwire, Roger Clemens, Rafael Palmeiro and all the other players who either have admitted or have allegedly used performance enhancing drugs (PEDs).
But then I read an exerpt of Zev Chafets’ book, Cooperstown Confidential: Heroes, Rogues and the Inside Story of the Baseball Hall of Fame, coming out next month.
I am now convinced that Manny, A-Rod, Clemens, McGwire are all no worse than who else is in the Baseball Hall of Fame.
Let’s start with a simple tutorial on how a player gets voted into the HOF. Player A is not eligible until seven years have passed since his retirement from playing. Once amount of time passes, Player A’s name gets on a list that goes to the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA). If Player A gets 75% or more of the votes from the writers, he gets enshrinement. Sounds simple, right?
Let’s move on to the next point Chafets makes.
“Not every immortal is a gentleman.”
Let’s look at some of the players currently in the HOF. Tris Speaker? Rogers Hornsby? Joe DiMaggio? Ty Cobb? Grover Cleveland Alexander? Mickey Mantle? Sandy Koufax? Even the last “pure” home run king, Hank Aaron?
Chances are you’ve heard of a few of these names and then some. Here’s why Chafets mentioned these names.
Ty Cobb was an avowed racist. He hated Jews and Blacks. He was known to raise his spikes when sliding if that opposing player was a Jew.
Tris Speaker and Rogers Hornsby were members of the Ku Klux Klan. Joe DiMaggio was a member of the mafia.
Grover Cleveland Alexander pitched a game drunk when alcohol was a federally banned substance.
Mickey Mantle was once forced out of the 1961 pennant race with an infection in his buttocks that he got from a quack doctor while shooting up a concoction of steroids and amphetamine.
Sandy Koufax took so much nonanabolic steroids for his pitching arm that on the mound he was sometimes “half-high.”
Finally — Hank Aaron? He has admitted to taking amphetamines.
All of the names above are in the HOF.
Of course, what did the voting members of the BBWAA do? Turn a blind eye. That is, until Jose Canseco wrote his book, spilling the beans about PED use in baseball. Since then, the BBWAA has gone with a vengeance against these cheaters.
What does that say about Manny Ramirez, Roger Clemens, or even A-Rod?
That means they should be compared against their contemporaries. Pretty much everyone, from the hitters to the pitchers, were doing PEDs in the late 1990s to early 2000s. Different eras, different stats. If A-Rod had more homers over a span of time than other players, then he was the better player — whether he did steroids or not.
Case in point: Before Babe Ruth came along, Home Run Baker was the leading home run hitter of his day. His highest single-season total? 12 home runs. That was in 1913.
In 1927, Babe Ruth hit a then-record 60 home runs in one season. See? Different eras, different stats.
You can bet I’ll run over to the book store and buy Chafets’ book and change my views of who should be in the Baseball Hall of Fame, and I suggest you do the same.
© Copyrighted material. This article cannot be copied, reproduced or redistributed without the express written consent of the author. As with every blog on this website, this blog does not reflect the opinion of DeafDC.com.








